Aston Villa striker Jhon Duran will face a three-match suspension after his red card in the 3-0 defeat to Newcastle United on Boxing Day was upheld on appeal.
Alan Shearer, the legendary former Newcastle striker, weighed in on the decision live during Amazon Prime’s coverage of Arsenal vs. Ipswich, expressing his thoughts on the controversial incident.
Duran’s dismissal came in the 32nd minute at St. James’ Park when he collided with Newcastle defender Fabian Schar while contesting a high ball. As Schar went to ground, Duran appeared to unintentionally step on the Swedish international, a motion seemingly unavoidable given the dynamics of the play. Despite the apparent lack of intent, referee Anthony Taylor issued a straight red card, which was later reviewed and upheld by VAR.
The Colombian international’s appeal to overturn the decision was dismissed, cementing his suspension and sparking debate within the footballing world. Shearer, speaking candidly on the matter, shared his perspective live on air, stating:
Advertisement
Latest Press Conference
We’re on Social Media
Follow us on X
See more football highlights
“Yeah, I’m not surprised. Once VAR got involved and the referee decided it was a red card, it was always going to be difficult to overturn. I thought it was harsh at the time, and my opinion hasn’t changed, but appeals rarely succeed in cases like this.”
The incident has left Aston Villa fans and pundits questioning the consistency of officiating and VAR’s application in high-stakes games. Many argue that the decision to send off Duran was overly punitive, given the lack of malicious intent and the circumstances of the collision.
A Harsh Call or the Right Decision?
Even with the benefit of video review, the decision to dismiss Duran continues to divide opinion. Meanwhile, from the replay, it’s clear the Villa forward had little control over where he landed after challenging for the ball. His foot’s contact with Schar appeared accidental, leading many to feel the punishment was disproportionate.
Critics of the red card argue that such incidents highlight the subjectivity of refereeing decisions, even with VAR in play. The failure of the appeal only adds to the frustration, as Aston Villa will now be without Duran during a crucial period in their season.
Aston Villa’s Dilemma
Duran’s suspension is a significant blow to Unai Emery’s side, particularly given the striker’s impressive form this season. His absence will be felt in the upcoming fixtures, where Aston Villa’s attacking depth will be put to the test.
However, the Villans have a capable alternative in Ollie Watkins, who will now have an opportunity to step up and solidify his role in the squad. Watkins has proven himself as a reliable goal scorer in the past, and this situation could reignite his drive to reclaim the starting spot.
Shearer’s Pragmatic Take
Alan Shearer’s reaction encapsulates the pragmatic understanding of how such decisions unfold in modern football. While acknowledging the harshness of the call, Shearer also recognized the challenges of overturning a referee’s on-field decision once VAR has intervened.
“It’s unfortunate for Villa and Duran,” Shearer added, “but when these decisions are made, they rarely get overturned, no matter how unfair they might seem.”
Moving Forward
For Aston Villa, the focus now shifts to adapting without Duran and ensuring the team remains competitive despite his absence. The club’s supporters, however, may continue to question the process that led to this outcome and the broader implications for officiating in the Premier League.
The controversy around Duran’s red card and suspension underscores the ongoing debate about VAR’s role in the game. While intended to bring clarity, incidents like this demonstrate how subjective interpretation can still leave teams and fans feeling aggrieved.
As Aston Villa prepares for their next match, the pressure will be on Emery’s squad to rally and prove their resilience. The loss to Newcastle and Duran’s suspension may sting, but the Villans have shown they can adapt and overcome challenges this season.