Paul Scholes has recently set the footballing world abuzz as he launched a scathing critique of Manchester United’s pricey defensive acquisitions.
He did not hold back on The Overlap Fan Debate, arguing that three of the club’s expensive centre-halves lack the quality needed to secure a Premier League title. Moreover, he warned that this approach could even risk relegation next season.
During his detailed analysis, Scholes expressed deep concern about the overall defensive strategy. He highlighted that the defensive frailties are not just a tactical issue but also a symptom of overspending without clear ambition. Furthermore, he stressed that high transfer fees alone cannot replace quality and cohesive teamwork.
United have invested heavily in their backline over recent seasons. For example, Harry Maguire arrived for £80m, Aaron Wan-Bissaka for £50m, and Victor Lindelof for £30.7m. Additionally, the controversial trio—Lisandro Martinez for £55m, Matthijs De Ligt for £38.5m, and Leny Yoro for £52m—amounts to roughly £145m, raising serious questions about the return on investment.
Scholes did not mince his words regarding Matthijs De Ligt. At 25 years old, De Ligt already boasts a varied club history, yet Scholes believes his form is in decline. He pointed out that although De Ligt shone at Ajax, both Bayern Munich and Juventus decided to let him go, suggesting that his potential may be diminishing.
Advertisement
Latest Press Conference
We’re on Social Media
Likewise, the young defender Leny Yoro, who is just 19, has failed to make the desired impact. Scholes recalled the Southampton game as an example and remarked that a centre-half should anchor a strong defensive spine. Therefore, despite Yoro’s youth and room for improvement, his current displays do not inspire confidence.
In a similar vein, Scholes criticized Lisandro Martinez by stating that even when fit, he does not meet the standards required to win the Premier League. Consequently, the Manchester United legend questioned the club’s ambition by asking if they truly believe that a defence built on such players can deliver the desired silverware.
United’s defensive record this season provides mixed signals. The team has conceded 34 goals, which is fewer than Manchester City, Tottenham, and Aston Villa. However, this figure pales in comparison to Liverpool’s 21 and Arsenal’s 22 goals conceded, indicating significant room for improvement. Moreover, Leny Yoro recently revealed on the Rio Ferdinand Presents podcast that the defenders use a WhatsApp group to share clips of opposing forwards’ movements—a tactical effort that underscores their need to learn and adapt.
In conclusion, Scholes firmly believes that further investment is necessary to bolster United’s defence. He recommended that the club acquire a new goalkeeper, additional centre halves, as well as midfielders and forwards with the right stature and quality to build a solid spine. Furthermore, he warned that if these strategic changes are not made this summer, Manchester United might face the unthinkable threat of relegation. Scholes delivered his incisive analysis on The Overlap Fan Debate, leaving fans to ponder the future direction of one of football’s most storied clubs.
