Pep Guardiola finds himself in uncharted waters at Manchester City, navigating a torrid stretch of form that has seen his team fail to win in seven consecutive matches across all competitions.
For a manager synonymous with success, this is more than just a dip—it’s a genuine crisis. The pressure reached new heights after a 2-0 defeat at Anfield, leaving City 11 points adrift of the Premier League summit.
Yet Guardiola, ever the optimist, has declared that this is the turning point. “Call me delusional,” he said following the loss to Liverpool, “but from here, I believe we will start to build back to winning games.” The question now is whether City can rise again, starting with a must-win clash against Nottingham Forest.
A Team Over-Reliant on Haaland
City’s struggles are epitomized by their dependence on Erling Haaland. The Norwegian has netted 12 goals this season, over half of the team’s 22 Premier League strikes. However, when Haaland falters—as he did during the 4-0 thrashing by Tottenham—the rest of the squad seems unable to step up.
Phil Foden has yet to open his account this season, hindered by fitness concerns, while other key players like John Stones, Kevin De Bruyne, and Mateo Kovacic have been sidelined with injuries. Even Guardiola’s tactical tweaks, which he has hinted were not universally embraced, have failed to reignite the team’s once-prolific attack.
For a side that has topped the league’s scoring charts every season under Guardiola, City’s current trajectory of 64 goals would mark a dramatic decline. Their struggles in build-up play, combined with nervous decision-making in midfield, have left Haaland isolated up front—a stark contrast to the fluidity of previous campaigns.
The De Bruyne Dilemma
Kevin De Bruyne’s prolonged absence has been a significant blow. The Belgian, grappling with a pelvic injury, has played just 71 minutes across the last five matches. Although De Bruyne insists he is managing his recovery carefully, the situation has raised eyebrows. Pundits have questioned why Guardiola hasn’t risked his talisman, especially during such a critical period.
The uncertainty surrounding De Bruyne’s fitness has fueled speculation about his future at the club. At 33, and with interest from leagues like Saudi Arabia and MLS, the midfielder could soon face a career-defining decision. For now, though, Guardiola needs him back on the pitch, dictating play and taking the risks that have made him one of the Premier League’s all-time greats.
Defensive Frailties Exposed
City’s defensive unit, once a bastion of stability, has also been alarmingly porous. Quickfire goals against opponents like Sporting Lisbon, Brighton, and Spurs have highlighted a lack of organization at the back. Ruben Dias, returning from injury, provided a glimmer of hope during the Liverpool defeat, but the team’s fragility remains a concern.
Dias, a leader both on and off the pitch, has been tasked with rallying the squad. His pre-match huddle at Anfield, though mocked for its clichés, underscored his determination to restore order. Guardiola must now decide whether to persist with recent experiments, such as benching Josko Gvardiol and Ederson, or return to tried-and-tested formulas.
Advertisement
Latest Press Conference
We’re on Social Media
Rebuilding Through the Transfer Market
City’s struggles have reignited discussions about squad depth and the need for reinforcements. Guardiola himself has admitted that a rebuild may be necessary, particularly in midfield. The injuries to Rodri and Kovacic have left the team short of options, while other areas, like attacking midfield, could also use fresh blood.
Potential targets, such as Bayer Leverkusen’s Florian Wirtz, would bring much-needed creativity, but competition for his signature will be fierce. City’s transfer policy, which has prioritized financial prudence in recent windows, may need to shift to ensure Guardiola has the tools to revitalize his squad.
The Mental Battle: Overcoming a Treble Hangover
Guardiola’s motivational skills have been tested like never before. After last season’s historic Treble, keeping the players hungry for more success has proved challenging. While the squad has publicly expressed accountability—captain Kyle Walker recently vowed that City will “come through this”—subconscious complacency may be harder to overcome.
The manager’s mountain analogy, used to galvanize the team post-Treble, seems less effective this time around. Extending records is a less compelling narrative than breaking them, and Guardiola must find a new way to inspire his players.
A Critical Moment in Guardiola’s Legacy
For all the speculation about squad dynamics and tactical tweaks, this slump could ultimately define Guardiola’s legacy at Manchester City. His ability to navigate this storm, reignite his team’s fire, and perhaps oversee a squad overhaul, will shape how this chapter of his career is remembered.
City’s clash with Nottingham Forest may not seem monumental on paper, but it could prove pivotal. A convincing win would restore belief, while another setback would deepen the crisis. Guardiola’s City have always thrived under pressure—now, more than ever, they need to show that resilience once again.
