As the winter transfer window drew to a close, Premier League clubs were scrambling to finalize deals, and Manchester City were no exception.
However, Paul Merson has voiced strong doubts about the £50m signing of Porto midfielder Nico Gonzalez, describing it as a “panic buy” that may not make much impact at the Etihad Stadium. Despite Gonzalez’s impressive performances at Porto this season, Merson believes the move raises questions about Manchester City’s transfer strategy, especially considering the club’s already stacked midfield.
Merson, speaking on Sky Sports, expressed concern over the timing of the transfer, noting that Manchester City already has a wealth of options in midfield. With Rodri recovering from a knee injury, the Spaniard’s absence has led City to explore alternatives, but Merson is unconvinced that Gonzalez will prove a valuable addition.
“They need players in midfield,” Merson said, “but it’s Rodri’s presence that makes all the difference. He’s disciplined, stays in the centre, reads the game, and protects the backline. I’m not sure Gonzalez can offer the same stability.” He further criticized Mateo Kovacic and Bernardo Silva for their lack of discipline in recent matches, particularly against Arsenal, where City struggled in key moments.
Advertisement
Latest Press Conference
We’re on Social Media
Merson’s primary concern with Gonzalez’s signing is that, upon Rodri’s return, the £50m man could be relegated to a bench role. “As soon as Rodri is fit, that’s it,” Merson argued. “Gonzalez won’t play unless City opt to pair them together, but I don’t think that’s necessary.
The problem is, with wages and buying players like this, you could see Gonzalez warming the bench, earning big money, but not playing regularly.” Merson’s assessment implies that this deal might not be the right move for City, especially if Gonzalez struggles to break into a team already dominated by established players in his position.
The concern also extends to City’s broader transfer strategy, with Merson suggesting that the club could be panicking to secure a top-four finish. “If they buy Gonzalez now, it seems like they’re trying to fill gaps quickly, perhaps fearing they’re not guaranteed a top-four spot this season,” he said. “It’s not just about the player—they’ll also have to manage players like James McAtee, a brilliant young talent who may be sold due to financial fair play rules.” This knock-on effect of signing high-value players without clear roles could have a long-term impact on the club’s squad balance.
Gonzalez Has Potential
Despite Merson’s criticism, Gonzalez has shown his potential at Porto, recording seven goals and six assists in all competitions this season. His form has caught the attention of several top clubs, and his versatility could prove useful to Manchester City, especially with their need for depth.
However, the reality of his integration into the Premier League side remains to be seen. With Rodri set to return to action in the Champions League knockout rounds, Gonzalez’s chances of regular first-team football could be limited, potentially making his £50m price tag seem excessive.
Ultimately, the true test of Gonzalez’s value will come when Rodri is fit and available. If the Spaniard regains his place in the starting lineup, the £50m investment in Gonzalez may appear less justified. Manchester City’s ambitions this season remain high, but with multiple midfield options and an already stacked squad, Merson’s critique underscores the potential risks of buying players under pressure without a clear tactical fit.
