The NFL is witnessing a quarterback shake-up in 2025, with 12 teams changing their Week 1 starters, including the Indianapolis Colts’ switch to Daniel Jones.
The league is abuzz as teams make bold moves, like the Colts’ announcement of Daniel Jones as their starting quarterback, marking a significant shift from last season. With the spotlight on these changes, questions arise about which teams are better off and which may regret their decisions. Let’s dive into the rankings of the 12 quarterbacks who have seen a switch, analyzing who got an upgrade and who may have taken a step back.
Starting off with Derek Carr, who led the charge for the Saints in 2024, we see a team that has yet to name a Week 1 starter, keeping fans on edge with a tight competition between two candidates. As the Saints prepare for a crucial preseason Week 3 clash against the Denver Broncos, the pressure is on to make the right choice that will set the tone for their season.
Anthony Richardson Sr.’s demotion by the Colts has raised eyebrows, signaling a setback for the team’s management and coaching staff. The decision to bench Richardson, a promising prospect under development, in favor of Jones, who showed modest stats during his time with the New York Giants, has left many questioning the Colts’ strategy moving forward.
Deshaun Watson’s replacement by Flacco for the Browns has brought a veteran presence to the team, following Flacco’s brief but successful stint in 2023. As Flacco, at 40, takes the reins, the Browns are hoping for a seamless transition and continued success on the field.
Each quarterback change brings its own set of challenges and opportunities, shaping the landscape of the NFL for the 2025 season. As teams adjust their strategies and refine their rosters, the upcoming games will reveal the true impact of these pivotal decisions on the field.