The protracted saga surrounding Manchester City’s 115 Premier League charges shows no signs of a swift resolution, with former Everton CEO Keith Wyness suggesting the appeal process could extend well into 2026. Speaking on a famous podcast, Wyness shared insights into the ongoing case, emphasizing the potential for a settlement to bring the matter to a close.
A Timeline of Turmoil
Manchester City was hit with 115 charges by the Premier League in February 2023, with allegations of financial fair play (FFP) breaches spanning a nine-year period from 2009 to 2018. These charges, which City have steadfastly denied, have cast a shadow over the club’s domestic and European campaigns, leaving fans and stakeholders awaiting clarity.
An independent commission began hearing the case in September 2024, and proceedings are set to conclude this week. However, as revealed by an online source on 21 November, a decision may not be published until the end of March 2025, further delaying any resolution.
Wyness Advocates for Common Sense
Wyness, now a football consultant advising elite clubs, hopes for a practical resolution. “Once the deliberations have been made public, I imagine there will be a lengthy document—three or four hundred pages detailing the findings,” he said. “What happens next depends on the verdict. There could be an appeal, or perhaps a settlement. I hope common sense prevails and that a settlement can be reached to put an end to this.”
The complexity of the case, compounded by the potential for appeals, means the timeline could stretch significantly. “If there is an appeal, this could go on much longer,” Wyness warned. “We could be looking at the end of 2025 or even 2026 before this is finally resolved.”
Advertisement
Latest Press Conference
We’re on Social Media
Settlement as a Possible Solution
Wyness’s suggestion of a settlement offers a glimmer of hope for a quicker resolution. Settlements are not unprecedented in football’s regulatory framework and could provide a way for all parties to avoid prolonged uncertainty. However, any agreement would depend heavily on the findings of the commission and whether both sides are willing to compromise.
Manchester City’s Stance
Throughout the process, Manchester City has vehemently denied the allegations and maintained their innocence. The club’s legal team is expected to robustly defend its position, but the sheer scale of the charges—115 in total—ensures a meticulous and time-consuming process.
The charges, covering sponsorship declarations, financial disclosures, and player contracts, have been a focal point of discussions about transparency and governance in the Premier League.
Appeals Process Could Further Prolong Resolution
If the commission’s verdict does not favor City, the club would likely pursue an appeal, adding months or even years to the timeline. The appeal could also open the door to further legal scrutiny, making a settlement an attractive alternative for avoiding a drawn-out battle.
Wyness acknowledged the toll such cases can take on clubs, leagues, and fans alike. “Let’s wait for the initial verdict and hope cooler heads prevail,” he said, emphasizing the importance of reaching a conclusion that restores focus to the pitch rather than the courtroom.
Broader Implications for the Premier League
This case holds significant ramifications beyond Manchester City. The Premier League’s handling of the charges and the eventual outcome will set a precedent for how financial breaches are addressed moving forward.
Recent high-profile cases, including Everton’s eight-point deduction for spending breaches, have demonstrated the league’s commitment to enforcing its rules. However, the length and complexity of such investigations also highlight the need for streamlined processes to ensure timely resolutions.
Fans Await Clarity
As City supporters anxiously await the outcome, the uncertainty surrounding the case has left an air of unease. Whether through a settlement or a definitive ruling, resolving the charges will be crucial for the club to move forward and focus on its on-field ambitions.
Looking Ahead
The conclusion of the independent commission’s hearing marks an important milestone, but the road to resolution remains long. Wyness’s comments underscore the potential for further delays, leaving stakeholders to ponder whether a settlement might be the most pragmatic solution.
For now, the football world watches closely, knowing the implications of this case could shape the Premier League’s financial governance for years to come.