The long-running saga of Manchester City’s 115 Premier League charges for alleged breaches of Financial Fair Play (FFP) rules could soon reach a pivotal moment.
Former Manchester City financial adviser Stefan Borson has shared his perspective on the timeline, predicting that the hearing may conclude as early as Tuesday.
Speaking to Football Insider, Borson explained that both the club and the Premier League’s legal teams began their closing arguments this week. The case, which centers around allegations of financial misconduct spanning nine years from 2009 to 2018, has been under the scrutiny of an independent commission since mid-September.
The hearing had paused in late November, granting both parties time to prepare their final submissions. According to Borson, these written arguments, likely spanning 25 to 50 pages, are integral to reinforcing their positions. “These documents reference key evidence and are designed to solidify each side’s case,” he explained. “They’ll likely spend two to three days presenting these arguments orally to the panel.”
The closing stages of the hearing gained attention earlier this week when a photograph surfaced online, showing the Premier League’s barristers, Andrew Hunter KC and Adam Lewis KC, returning to the International Dispute Resolution Centre in London. This prompted speculation that the process was entering its final phase.
Borson outlined the expected timeline: “If the presentations began mid-week, they might wrap up by Monday or Tuesday. Once the oral arguments conclude, the panel will move into the deliberation phase to reach a verdict.”
Advertisement
Latest Press Conference
We’re on Social Media
The case, initially brought to light in February 2023, has become a landmark moment in the Premier League’s enforcement of financial regulations. The allegations against Manchester City include providing inaccurate financial information, particularly regarding sponsorship deals and operating costs, potentially breaching the league’s FFP framework.
As the hearing edges closer to a conclusion, attention turns to the potential implications for Manchester City. While the club has consistently denied any wrongdoing, maintaining its compliance with FFP rules, the sheer scale of the charges has fueled widespread speculation about possible sanctions.
The timeline for a decision from the independent commission remains uncertain. Still, given the complexity of the case, it’s expected that a comprehensive review of the evidence will take time. Borson suggested that the panel’s verdict might not be imminent, emphasizing the need for thorough consideration before any ruling is made.
Beyond the legal ramifications, the hearing has also reignited debates about the Premier League’s regulatory framework. Critics argue that the prolonged process highlights inefficiencies, while others see it as a necessary step toward ensuring transparency and accountability in football finance.
As Manchester City awaits the outcome, the broader footballing world watches with keen interest. Whether the panel upholds the charges or exonerates the club, the decision is likely to have far-reaching consequences for both Manchester City and the Premier League’s approach to governance.
