James McAtee: A Star Waiting to Shine for Manchester City

Three years ago, James McAtee’s Premier League debut for Manchester City lasted all of three minutes against Everton.

In that brief moment, he earned a glowing comparison to David Silva from Gary Neville, who described him as a “clone” of the legendary Spaniard. Yet, since that day, McAtee has made just three more minutes of top-flight appearances for the club. For a player of his talent, the wait has been agonizingly long.

Two seasons on loan at Sheffield United, where he experienced both promotion and relegation, refined McAtee into a more complete footballer. Over the summer, the sentiment around City—echoed by Pep Guardiola’s own words—was that McAtee’s time to shine had finally arrived. Clubs like Nottingham Forest, Lens, and Lille expressed interest, but Guardiola made it clear to sporting director Txiki Begiristain that McAtee was neither for sale nor loan. The plan? To ease him into games and let his creativity unlock opposition defenses.

McAtee seemed ready for the challenge. During City’s preseason tour in North Carolina, he spoke about his aspirations. “It’s my dream to play for this club,” he said with quiet determination. “I just want to learn from the best and earn my chances.” But as City endured a dismal run of form, winning just once in 13 matches before their visit to Leicester City, McAtee’s patience has been severely tested. Watching from the sidelines, bundled in his club coat, he cuts a frustrated figure—a player with talent to offer but no platform to showcase it.

Advertisement

Latest Press Conference

We’re on Social Media

Follow us on X
See more football highlights

In an injury-hit season that has exposed City’s vulnerabilities, McAtee’s skillset could be a much-needed spark. Guardiola has often praised his ability to operate in tight spaces, a trait that could have made a difference in games like the Boxing Day stalemate against Everton. With City struggling to break down stubborn defenses, what harm would there be in giving McAtee a chance?

This season, McAtee has made eight appearances across all competitions, totaling just 333 minutes. Under normal circumstances, that might be an acceptable tally for a young player breaking through. However, with City’s well-documented struggles and the departures of academy talents like Cole Palmer, Liam Delap, and Romeo Lavia, questions are being raised about the club’s handling of its brightest prospects.

The parallels between McAtee and Palmer are striking. Palmer, now thriving at Chelsea, often struggled for minutes at City but shone on the international stage with England’s Under-21s. McAtee is experiencing a similar trajectory, consistently delivering standout performances for the Young Lions. His goals and playmaking have made him a central figure in a squad filled with Premier League regulars, underscoring his readiness for a bigger role at club level.

Palmer’s Story

Palmer’s story serves as a cautionary tale for City. Despite limited opportunities at club level, Palmer’s class eventually prevailed, culminating in a starring role during England’s Under-21 European Championship triumph. McAtee, too, has the potential to emulate Palmer’s success, but only if given the chance to prove himself.

The upcoming transfer window presents a critical juncture for McAtee. Clubs like West Ham are reportedly interested, and the 22-year-old might need to push for a move if his situation at City doesn’t improve. Guardiola has publicly stated that he doesn’t want to shrink his squad further, but McAtee’s development could be stunted if he remains on the fringes.

In October, McAtee showcased his ability with a well-taken goal against Slovan Bratislava in the Champions League. The move, orchestrated by Rico Lewis and Phil Foden, highlighted the chemistry he shares with fellow academy graduates. McAtee’s subsequent appearances against Sparta Prague and Tottenham in the Carabao Cup further demonstrated his versatility and composure.

James McAtee needs more minutes

Yet, moments like his late substitution against Feyenoord, where City squandered a three-goal lead, have added to McAtee’s frustration. Despite assurances from teammates and coaches that he wasn’t at fault, such experiences can weigh heavily on a young player’s confidence. For McAtee, the challenge lies in balancing perseverance with the need for regular game time.

England’s Under-21 setup has become a sanctuary for McAtee. His performances have not gone unnoticed by the FA, which views him as a potential senior international. With the Young Lions preparing for next summer’s tournament, concerns are growing that City’s participation in the Club World Cup could limit McAtee’s availability. Losing him would be a blow to England’s hopes, given his ability to dictate games and deliver in crucial moments.

The situation is a delicate one for City. On one hand, they recognize McAtee’s immense potential and the value he brings to the squad. On the other, their track record with academy graduates raises questions about whether he’ll get the opportunities he deserves. For McAtee, the time to step out of the shadows and into the spotlight is now. Whether that happens at City or elsewhere remains to be seen.