Giants signal to Daniel Jones: perform or prepare to pack

The New York Giants have subtly reminded quarterback Daniel Jones that his job security might not be as stable as once thought.

Since securing a substantial contract extension last season, Jones has yet to deliver on the promise the organization saw in him. His performance thus far has raised questions, as the Giants struggle through a tough season, leaving both fans and management wondering if extending Jones was indeed the best choice for the franchise.

In the 2023 offseason, the Giants faced a franchise-altering decision: extend Jones as their quarterback or retain star running back Saquon Barkley. They opted for Jones, parting ways with Barkley in the belief that Jones was the long-term solution they needed under center. However, as Barkley thrives with the Philadelphia Eagles, it’s becoming painfully evident that the Giants may have made the wrong choice.

Jones’s on-field struggles have cast a long shadow over the franchise’s initial confidence. With the Giants off to a disappointing 2-8 start in the 2024 NFL season, Jones’s record since signing his contract is a paltry 3-13. The dismal stats have led to growing calls from fans and analysts alike for the Giants to explore alternative options. Head coach Brian Daboll addressed the rising questions about Jones’s performance, subtly signaling that the team’s patience may be wearing thin.

The Giants’ choice to extend Jones over Barkley now looks like a major misstep, especially with Barkley excelling in his new role with Philadelphia. Giants fans are left wondering what might have been if the front office had made a different call. Barkley’s resurgence has only underscored Jones’s faltering play and highlighted the challenges the Giants face without a strong running game to support their offense. It’s a painful juxtaposition for Giants fans who were hoping Jones would cement himself as the franchise leader.

The dissatisfaction is now palpable, and Daboll’s recent comments only heighten the sense of urgency surrounding Jones’s role. Giants General Manager Joe Schoen and Daboll both emphasized that evaluations are happening across all positions, implying that Jones isn’t immune to scrutiny. “There’s good communication [with ownership],” Daboll said, adding that any position, not just quarterback, could be subject to change if necessary. The statement suggests the Giants’ tolerance may be waning if Jones can’t pull himself—and the team—out of the slump.

The Giants’ decision-makers must now assess whether Jones can deliver the consistency they need from their starting quarterback. Daboll’s comments are likely intended to motivate Jones, a reminder that the organization has a responsibility to field a competitive team, and no position is sacred if it becomes a liability. The message: Jones must either improve or risk finding himself benched, as the team looks to restore its competitive edge.

Advertisement

We’re on Social Media

Follow us on X
See more football highlights

From a financial standpoint, parting ways with Jones after the 2024 season would be an expensive decision. Cutting him would lead to a hefty $22 million dead cap hit for 2025. This financial penalty makes the decision to move on from Jones even more complex. The team would have to carefully weigh the cost of keeping an underperforming quarterback against the financial burden of releasing him.

With limited cap space and a roster in flux, the Giants may feel compelled to seek alternative options at quarterback if Jones’s performance doesn’t improve. The dead cap hit would be significant, but the potential benefits of moving on could ultimately outweigh the costs. The team’s commitment to winning, combined with Jones’s lackluster results, puts him in an uncertain position, and the pressure is mounting to see improvement soon.

Jones now faces a critical stretch that will likely define his future in New York. If he can rally and elevate his play, he may secure his role; otherwise, the Giants may explore trades, drafts, or free-agent signings to solidify the quarterback position. For Jones, it’s a defining moment to either prove himself or risk becoming a high-profile casualty in the team’s quest to return to winning form.

The Giants’ fans are clamoring for a turnaround, and patience is running thin. The team’s missteps in recent years, from draft picks to player retention, have worn down the fan base’s confidence. Now, the spotlight is squarely on Jones to deliver or face the reality that he may not be the quarterback the Giants need.

Ultimately, while Jones’s future remains uncertain, the message from the Giants organization is crystal clear: every game from here on out is an audition, and without marked improvement, his time as the Giants’ starter could be nearing an end. As the 2024 season rolls on, Jones’s play will either silence the critics or signal the Giants to start exploring new leadership under center.