Everton and Manchester United clashed at Goodison Park in a match filled with drama and heated debate.
Referee Andy Madley initially signaled a stoppage-time penalty for the Toffees. However, he quickly overturned his decision following a VAR review.
Ashley Young went down in the box after Matthijs de Ligt and Harry Maguire got involved. Madley pointed to the spot before VAR official Matt Donohue instructed him to review the incident. The referee changed his mind after Young’s theatrical fall.
Tensions boiled over in the tunnel after the decision. England teammates Jordan Pickford and Harry Maguire engaged in a debate over the call. James Tarkowski lightened the mood with a playful remark directed at Maguire.
Everton defender Jake O’Brien did not hold back his criticism. He insisted the penalty was obvious and felt it altered the game’s outcome. O’Brien believes Madley made several wrong calls during the match.
Advertisement
Latest Press Conference
We’re on Social Media
United boss Ruben Amorim called the decision “soft” and hinted that the call was lenient for an English game. He admitted he did not view the play clearly but stood by his assessment. Amorim’s comments added fuel to an already intense situation.
Despite the controversy, Everton transformed disappointment into progress. The Toffees have secured 14 points in David Moyes’ first seven games back at Goodison Park. This marks a promising start for a rejuvenated side.
O’Brien’s resurgence at Everton contrasts sharply with his time under Sean Dyche. The 23-year-old Republic of Ireland defender made just two Premier League appearances after a £15m move from Lyon. Now, under Moyes, he has started seven out of eight games.
O’Brien now plays at right back instead of his favoured central role, and he has embraced the new challenge. He credits Moyes for trusting him and giving him a run of games. His determination signals a bright future for Everton and for his own career.
