The Dallas Cowboys have officially named Cooper Rush as their starter while Dak Prescott recovers from a significant hamstring injury.
After careful evaluation, including game performances in Week 10, the Cowboys coaching staff, led by Mike McCarthy, decided that Rush provides the best chance for continuity as the team navigates the season without their franchise quarterback. The 2024 season has been rocky for Dallas, and this latest setback is adding to the challenges as the team fights to keep its playoff aspirations alive.
When Prescott was sidelined in Week 9, the Cowboys knew they’d be facing difficult decisions. Initial reports indicated that the injury might sideline him for at least four games. Prescott’s absence now places the Cowboys at a pivotal point in their season. Cooper Rush and Trey Lance were both under consideration to fill Prescott’s shoes, but each quarterback’s recent performance made the final decision clearer.
Prescott’s injury could not have come at a worse time for Dallas, as their 5-4 record has put them on the playoff bubble. Though Prescott’s season had its ups and downs, he remains the best option to lead this offense, but without him, the Cowboys have had to weigh the benefits of Rush’s game management against Lance’s athletic potential. Rush, who led the Cowboys through tough stretches in past seasons, ultimately received the nod after Week 10, in which both quarterbacks were put to the test against the Philadelphia Eagles.
In Week 10, Rush completed just 13 of 23 passes for 45 yards with no touchdowns. This conservative performance seemed to embody his risk-averse, steady approach as a backup. Following Rush, McCarthy gave Lance a chance, but Lance’s outing—a 4-of-6 passing attempt for only 21 yards and one interception—left much to be desired. The decision to start Rush was, therefore, likely based on limiting mistakes rather than seeking explosive plays.
The Cowboys are now moving forward with Rush under center as they prepare to take on the Houston Texans in Week 11. While McCarthy acknowledges that Rush’s stats from Week 10 were underwhelming, he’s betting on Rush’s experience and familiarity with the Cowboys’ system to stabilize the team. Though Lance showed flashes of potential, his inconsistent accuracy and the costly interception left McCarthy with little choice.
As Rush takes the helm, the Cowboys’ offense will need to adjust. McCarthy and offensive coordinator Brian Schottenheimer are likely designing a more conservative game plan, focusing on the ground game and quick, high-percentage passing plays to control the clock and reduce turnovers. Rush’s ability to execute a simplified scheme could be critical to keeping the Cowboys afloat in Prescott’s absence, though the margin for error is slim.
This shift also casts serious doubt on Trey Lance’s future with the team. Lance, acquired from the 49ers, was initially thought to bring added depth and potential as a long-term option. But after inconsistent performances, both in practice and games, Lance’s place on the 2025 roster is no longer secure. With Prescott’s return on the horizon and Rush now firmly entrenched as the backup, the Cowboys may look to move Lance by season’s end.
In terms of strategy, the Cowboys are entering a crucial stretch where they cannot afford more losses. The NFC East is competitive, and Dallas’s playoff hopes rely on consistent performances and avoiding further injuries. A strong showing from Rush would keep the Cowboys in contention, but the looming question remains: Can Rush do enough to give Dallas a fighting chance, or will Prescott’s absence define a disappointing season?
Advertisement
We’re on Social Media
Follow us on X
See more football highlights
Another factor adding pressure is the Cowboys’ upcoming schedule, filled with challenging matchups that will test Rush’s capabilities. With games against high-caliber defenses, Rush’s performance in these critical weeks could determine whether the Cowboys remain in the playoff hunt or begin looking towards next season.
The decision to start Rush speaks to the Cowboys’ cautious approach to roster management. McCarthy and team ownership likely view this season as one in which a stable hand at quarterback can be enough to stay competitive until Prescott’s return. Lance’s developmental curve appears too steep for immediate gains, and thus, for the Cowboys, Rush’s steady approach seems the safer gamble for Week 11 and beyond.
Looking forward, if Prescott’s absence stretches further, Rush may find himself with an extended opportunity to prove his mettle. However, if he struggles, McCarthy may be forced to revisit Lance as an option. For now, though, it’s clear that the Cowboys are leaning into Rush’s consistency over Lance’s raw potential.
The Cowboys’ 2024 season hangs in the balance, with Rush now entrusted to steer the ship in Prescott’s absence. While fans may have hoped for more dynamic performances from Lance, McCarthy’s choice reveals the team’s pragmatic approach to the present crisis. As Week 11 approaches, all eyes are on Cooper Rush as he steps into one of the NFL’s most scrutinized roles: starting quarterback for the Dallas Cowboys.