Ange Postecoglou’s tenure at Tottenham Hotspur is under increasing scrutiny following claims of a falling out with several senior players this season.
While the 59-year-old manager’s straight-talking approach initially earned him praise, there are now growing concerns regarding his ability to maintain harmony within the squad and lead Spurs to success. Recent reports indicate that Postecoglou has clashed with at least four of his top players, and despite early optimism, the situation at Tottenham is starting to show signs of unrest.
When Postecoglou was appointed in the summer of 2023, many Spurs fans viewed his arrival as a breath of fresh air. His direct and no-nonsense attitude quickly resonated with both supporters and the media. Coupled with a dynamic, attacking brand of football, the club seemed poised for a successful campaign. Tottenham were flying high in the early part of the 2023-24 Premier League season, winning eight of their first ten matches, with many tipping them as potential contenders.
However, fast forward to the current season, and the mood has shifted dramatically. Tottenham are struggling to find consistency, suffering three defeats in their last five Premier League games and languishing in 10th place in the table. The club’s shocking 2-1 loss to Ipswich at the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium—marking Ipswich’s first Premier League win in over 8,000 days—only added fuel to the fire, with fans and pundits alike questioning what has gone wrong.
As the pressure mounts, new reports have emerged suggesting that Postecoglou’s relationship with several key players has become increasingly strained. Football Insider has claimed that Postecoglou has had a fallout with at least four senior stars this season, including Italy internationals Destiny Udogie and Guglielmo Vicario, as well as South American duo Rodrigo Bentancur and Cristian Romero. The report suggests that Postecoglou’s blunt and sometimes abrasive communication style, both in public and behind closed doors, has caused friction within the dressing room, potentially contributing to the team’s erratic performances.
Sources close to the situation indicate that Postecoglou’s straightforward approach may have backfired, with some players reacting negatively to his frankness. The discord in the dressing room appears to be having a detrimental effect on the team’s cohesion, and the club’s wildly inconsistent form this season may be a reflection of this internal tension. Tottenham’s performance in recent weeks—particularly the surprise loss to Ipswich—has only amplified concerns about Postecoglou’s leadership and ability to manage the dressing room effectively.
Advertisement
We’re on Social Media
Follow us on X
See more football highlights
Despite the growing speculation surrounding his future, it is important to note that Postecoglou is not under immediate threat of the sack. Senior sources within Tottenham have suggested that the club’s board remains committed to the Australian manager for now, with a key period ahead after the international break. Tottenham’s next fixture, a home match against Manchester City on November 23, could prove pivotal in determining Postecoglou’s future. A strong performance and a positive result against one of the Premier League’s heavyweights could ease some of the mounting pressure.
Moreover, despite recent struggles, Postecoglou still has notable victories under his belt. Wins over Manchester United, Manchester City (in the Carabao Cup), and Aston Villa have demonstrated the potential within the squad. Additionally, Tottenham’s European campaign in the Europa League remains on track, with Spurs set to progress to the knockout stages despite a setback in Turkey against Galatasaray. Postecoglou’s desire to lift silverware with Tottenham—who have not won a major trophy since 2008—remains a key motivating factor.
Tottenham’s ambitions for this season are clear, with Postecoglou tasked with delivering a spot in the Champions League for the club, as set by chairman Daniel Levy. The Europa League offers a potential pathway to this goal, and success in the competition could provide the necessary momentum to turn around the club’s fortunes in the Premier League. However, the manager’s position is likely to be reassessed if Spurs fail to improve over the coming weeks.
Despite the murmurs of discontent surrounding Postecoglou, football pundits like Alan Shearer and Evening Standard journalist Dan Kilpatrick have sought to temper speculation about his immediate future. Shearer, speaking on The Rest is Football podcast, dismissed the idea of Postecoglou being under serious threat, pointing out that Tottenham’s inconsistencies are nothing new. “Typical Spurs though, isn’t it? One minute they’re beating City and Villa, and the next they lose to Ipswich,” Shearer remarked, emphasizing that it was far too soon to panic over the manager’s position.
Kilpatrick echoed these sentiments, stating on the Tottenham Way podcast that the club seems committed to a medium-term project under Postecoglou. He highlighted that the club’s recent transfer activity, including the acquisition of younger players, points to a longer-term vision, with a focus on building a competitive squad for the future. Kilpatrick suggested that, while frustration may be growing among some supporters, the club’s leadership appears prepared to stick with Postecoglou through this turbulent period.
With Postecoglou’s future hanging in the balance, Tottenham’s upcoming fixtures will be crucial in determining whether he can weather the storm. A successful run of results in the coming month—starting with the showdown against Manchester City—could allow the manager to regain some much-needed momentum. However, if Tottenham’s struggles continue, the club may be forced to reconsider their stance.
Meanwhile, Tottenham are already looking ahead to the January transfer window, with reports suggesting that the club is eyeing up new recruits to strengthen the squad. Real Betis midfielder Johnny Cardoso, who Spurs secured first refusal on in the summer, is reportedly set to be their first signing of 2025. Additionally, there is speculation surrounding Greek striker Stefanos Tzimas, who has impressed during a loan spell at Nurnberg. The club is also said to be monitoring Takefusa Kubo of Real Sociedad, highlighting their ongoing ambitions to strengthen their squad regardless of Postecoglou’s future.
In conclusion, while the recent reports of Postecoglou’s fallouts with senior players and the club’s inconsistent form have fueled doubts about his long-term viability, it is clear that the club remains committed to him for the time being. Spurs’ upcoming fixtures will be critical in determining whether Postecoglou can turn the situation around and secure his position at the club. If he can navigate these challenges successfully, he may yet lead Tottenham to the success they crave. However, if the team’s struggles continue, both on and off the pitch, the pressure will only continue to grow.