The NBA’s decision to overhaul the All-Star Game format for 2025 has sparked intense debate among players and fans alike.
The league’s announcement of a four-team, three-game structure, set to debut on February 16 at Chase Center in San Francisco, has been met with criticism from several marquee players. Leading the charge are Anthony Davis of the Los Angeles Lakers, Devin Booker of the Phoenix Suns, and their teammate Kevin Durant, all of whom have expressed skepticism about the new direction.
Davis, known for his on-court dominance and candid off-court remarks, didn’t hold back when asked about the revamped format. “I don’t really like it, but we’ll see how it goes this year,” he said. While open to giving it a try, Davis made it clear he prefers a return to the traditional East vs. West structure. “I want two teams—if anything, go back to East and West,” he added, echoing a sentiment that seems to resonate with many of his peers.
The new format, which aims to inject innovation into the All-Star experience, has sparked concerns about its impact on the quality of play and player engagement. Davis voiced his apprehension, predicting a lack of enthusiasm from players. “Four teams and multiple games… I don’t think a lot of players are gonna like that,” he stated, anticipating that the change might alienate participants and audiences alike.
Devin Booker also weighed in, offering his perspective on the shift. The Suns’ star guard underscored the nostalgic appeal of the classic format, noting its importance in preserving the essence of the game. “It’s change; it’s different. I’m more into the nostalgia,” Booker said. “I agree with Kev. I like East vs. West, with your own team jersey. Also, I like the old jerseys.”
Advertisement
Latest Press Conference
We’re on Social Media
Booker’s remarks reflect a broader sense of discontent among players who value the traditional structure. For many, the classic East vs. West matchup, complete with team-specific jerseys, represents a time when the All-Star Game celebrated the league’s storied history. The new format, by contrast, risks prioritizing entertainment value over tradition, a move that has left many players feeling disconnected.
Davis’s critique goes beyond nostalgia, pointing to the potential pitfalls of the league’s gamble on innovation. “It feels like we’re straying too far from what made the All-Star Game special in the first place,” he explained. Both he and Booker emphasized that the league should tread carefully, balancing its desire for novelty with a respect for tradition.
NBA intent on new format
The NBA’s intent behind the new format is clear: to reimagine the All-Star Game as a more dynamic, fast-paced event that appeals to younger fans. By introducing a multi-team, multi-game setup, the league hopes to create fresh excitement and draw in a wider audience. However, this strategy comes with significant risks, particularly if it fails to resonate with the league’s core players and longtime supporters.
Kevin Durant’s criticism of the new format further highlights the challenges facing the NBA. His concerns, shared by Davis and Booker, signal a growing disconnect between the league’s vision and the players’ expectations. The backlash suggests that the league may need to reconsider its approach if it hopes to maintain the All-Star Game’s status as a marquee event.
Delicate balancing act
Nostalgia has emerged as a powerful force in the players’ critiques, with Booker’s and Davis’s comments highlighting a longing for the simplicity and authenticity of past All-Star Games. Their call to return to the East vs. West format underscores a broader desire to preserve the game’s historical significance while staying true to its roots.
The NBA now faces a delicate balancing act: how to innovate without alienating its most important stakeholders. For stars like Davis and Booker, the All-Star Game is more than just an exhibition—it’s a celebration of the league’s legacy and a showcase of its brightest talent. Striking the right balance between tradition and innovation will be critical to ensuring the game’s continued success.
As the league prepares for the debut of its new All-Star format, the mixed reactions from players like Davis and Booker serve as a reminder of the challenges inherent in change. Whether the new structure will ultimately succeed or fall flat remains to be seen, but one thing is clear: the voices of the players will play a pivotal role in shaping the future of the All-Star Game.
