Aston Villa may face a tricky balancing act this winter as the club looks to secure a major contract for Morgan Rogers, with former Villa CEO Keith Wyness suggesting that player sales could be a necessary step to fund the deal.
The 22-year-old, who joined the club from Middlesbrough earlier this year, has quickly established himself as a key figure under Unai Emery. Following his stellar performances, Rogers is set to receive a significant pay rise, but the move could trigger a deeper financial dilemma for the club.
Wyness, who served as Aston Villa’s CEO between 2016 and 2018 and now advises top clubs through his consultancy, spoke candidly on Football Insider’s Inside Track podcast about the financial implications Villa could face as they look to reward Rogers for his excellent form. “It’s a classic football dilemma,” said Wyness. “You’ve got the young talent coming through, like Duran and Rogers – and you don’t want to lose them. But at the same time, you’ve got the Profit and Sustainability Rules (PSR) to consider.”
The Morgan Rogers Dilemma: A Rising Star’s Pay Rise
Morgan Rogers joined Villa in February 2024 on a relatively modest contract after an impressive spell at Middlesbrough, and his rise has been swift. The winger has caught the eye with his dynamic performances, contributing significantly to Villa’s attack this season. It’s no surprise that Villa are eager to reward Rogers with a new contract that reflects his growing importance in the team. However, with the club’s financial situation in mind, there’s a looming question of how they’ll manage to fit this deal within the constraints of financial fair play regulations.
Wyness acknowledged that Villa’s sporting director, Monchi, and his team will have a strategy in place. “Monchi and his colleagues will understand the situation, and will have a plan,” Wyness said, adding that the experienced operator is already likely plotting how to balance the books. “They’ll know where they are going to divest, they know where they have excess players.”
Advertisement
Latest Press Conference
We’re on Social Media
PSR Concerns: Could Player Sales Be Necessary?
The Profit and Sustainability Rules, which are closely tied to financial fair play (FFP) regulations, are a constant concern for clubs like Villa, who are striving to build a competitive squad while ensuring they don’t breach financial guidelines. Aston Villa, like many Premier League clubs, must ensure that their spending on wages and transfers doesn’t exceed their revenue growth. As Wyness pointed out, the club’s increasing wage bill, spurred by the contracts of emerging talents like Rogers and Jhon Duran, could push Villa close to a financial ceiling.
Wyness emphasized that while Villa are keen to hold onto their key players, some difficult decisions may lie ahead. “You’ve got to find that balance, and if you’ve got excess players or players who are not in the long-term plans, you might have to make some moves,” he explained. “That’s what Monchi will have to look at. He’s a consummate operator, so he’ll have already planned for this.”
Jhon Duran’s New Deal Adds to the Financial Complexity
Jhon Duran, another young player who has impressed this season, also signed a new lucrative deal recently. The Colombian forward has been a standout for Villa, contributing both goals and assists in the early stages of the 2024-25 campaign. His contract extension, while deserved, further complicates Villa’s financial landscape as the club looks to secure long-term deals for their young talents while adhering to financial regulations.
Duran’s contract, alongside Rogers’ impending pay rise, means Villa could face difficult decisions when it comes to squad management. The club may have to evaluate whether some of their surplus players, or those on the fringes of the squad, will need to be sold in order to stay within the financial parameters set by the Premier League.
The Future of Aston Villa’s Squad: Potential Outgoings
While there is a clear desire to keep emerging stars like Rogers and Duran, it’s equally important for Villa to keep a keen eye on squad balance. Financial constraints could lead to the sale of players who are deemed surplus to requirements, and Monchi’s task will be to identify where the club has excess talent and which players could bring in valuable funds.
The club’s recent successes in the transfer market, coupled with their rise in the Premier League standings, have given them more leverage, but they are still bound by the same financial restrictions as any other club in the top flight. As Villa look to build a squad capable of competing for European spots, the reality of managing finances while retaining key players will require tactical decisions in the transfer window.
The Role of Monchi and Strategic Player Management
As one of the most highly regarded sporting directors in European football, Monchi will be crucial to navigating these financial challenges. Known for his ability to make shrewd signings and sell players for profit, Monchi will likely have a plan in place to ensure Villa remain competitive while avoiding any financial pitfalls. The club has already made significant strides in building a solid squad under Unai Emery, and Monchi’s expertise will continue to play a vital role in future planning.
“The key for Villa will be ensuring they don’t overextend themselves financially,” Wyness noted. “Monchi is well aware of that, and I’m sure he’ll be looking at ways to balance the books while still strengthening the squad. Whether that involves player sales or other strategies, Villa will have a plan.”
A Critical Winter for Aston Villa’s Finances and Squad Development
With the January transfer window fast approaching, Villa’s financial situation will come into sharper focus. The club will need to carefully evaluate their options, especially with the rising costs associated with renewing contracts for their young stars. The possibility of selling players to fund moves for key targets is always present, and Villa’s top brass will have to weigh the risk of losing key assets against the need to comply with financial regulations.
Wyness concluded by stating that while it’s certainly a challenging situation, Aston Villa is in good hands. “It’s definitely something they will have to be concerned about, but Monchi is the kind of operator who will figure it out,” he said. “Villa are building something good, and with the right planning, they’ll manage this well.”
As Aston Villa continue their rise under Emery’s guidance, the next few months could be pivotal for the club’s long-term financial sustainability and their ambitions to break into the European elite. How they navigate these financial constraints will likely shape their transfer strategy in the coming seasons.
