David Moyes’ Return to Everton: Paul Mearson Slams Scott’s Choice

The return of David Moyes to Everton has sparked heated debates among fans and pundits alike.

Paul Mearson, offering his perspective, sees the appointment as a step backwards for the club. Mearson’s suggestion? Lee Carsley could have been the better, long-term choice for a struggling Everton side desperate for stability.

Moyes’ appointment comes at a turbulent time for Everton, who find themselves deep in a relegation battle. As Mearson points out, the team is struggling to find the back of the net and has been losing games with alarming regularity. Despite his track record, Moyes faces an uphill battle to stabilize a squad that doesn’t even seem capable of mounting a credible attacking threat.

“They can’t score a goal. Losing games for fun. They don’t even look like scoring a goal,” Mearson bluntly noted, highlighting the grim reality at Goodison Park. Moyes himself, in a recent comment, had expressed his preference to avoid another relegation dogfight—a sentiment that now seems ironic given the state of his new side. Everton’s struggles present him with precisely the challenge he hoped to evade.

Reflecting on Moyes’ return, Mearson’s skepticism is evident. “You don’t go back,” he said. “People keep saying, ‘Oh, he knows the club inside out.’ He left 11 years ago.” For Mearson, the notion that Moyes’ previous tenure gives him an advantage now seems misplaced. Eleven years is a long time in football, and both the club and the Premier League have evolved significantly since his departure.

Advertisement

Latest Press Conference

We’re on Social Media

Follow us on X
See more football highlights

Mearson’s analysis delves deeper into the structural challenges facing Moyes. “When a manager comes into a struggling team, you often have players who’ve fallen out of favor but might thrive under new leadership. Moyes doesn’t have that luxury here. This is the team. There aren’t hidden gems waiting to be discovered.” The implication is clear: Moyes will have to work with what he has, and that may not be enough to steer Everton to safety.

While Mearson doesn’t discount Moyes’ managerial pedigree, he remains critical of the decision to rehire him. “Don’t get me wrong, I like David Moyes,” he clarified. “But this feels like a decision rooted in nostalgia rather than strategy.” For Everton, a club in dire need of fresh ideas and long-term vision, a different approach might have been more prudent.

Everton Needed Another Name

So, who would Mearson have turned to? His choice is clear: Lee Carsley. The former Everton midfielder and current coach has built a strong reputation, and Mearson believes he could bring both immediate results and a sustainable future to the club. “I’d have gone to see about Lee Carsley,” Mearson explained. “Not just for the next three or four months, but for the long-term. He could build something at Everton.”

For Mearson, Carsley represents a forward-thinking option—a manager who could instill a clear identity and foster development. In contrast, Moyes’ appointment feels like a temporary fix, one that may not address the deeper issues plaguing the club.

Ultimately, Everton’s decision to bring back Moyes reflects the precarious position the club finds itself in. With survival in the Premier League hanging in the balance, the board’s priority is short-term stability. However, as Mearson’s critique highlights, this approach could come at the expense of long-term progress.

The challenge for Moyes is immense. To prove Mearson and other skeptics wrong, he must not only guide Everton away from the relegation zone but also lay the groundwork for a brighter future. Whether he can achieve that remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: the pressure at Goodison Park has never been higher.